Playback serverIf a title won’t play, switch servers.

Creep Cast

Season 1 · Episode 51

I Wrote Myself a Letter, I Got a Response

0.02h 13mApril 6, 2025

Isaiah and Hunter read a story where a 25-year-old man named Scott writes a letter to himself. He receives a physical reply, but things escalate into a dark, disturbing psychological and supernatural trap involving twisted realities and desperate choices. Author: Verastahl

Previous Episode Next Episode

Episodes

Episode 1The Stairs in the Woods
Episode 2Jeff the Killer
Episode 3The Russian Sleep Experiment
Episode 4Borrasca Pt. 1
Episode 5Borrasca Pt. 2
Episode 6My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me on Facebook
Episode 7Penpal
Episode 8Left Right Game Pt. 1
Episode 9Left Right Game Pt. 2
Episode 10Gr3gory88
Episode 11The Thing in the Basement is Getting Better at Mimicking People
Episode 121999
Episode 13The Showers
Episode 14NoEnd House
Episode 15Creepy Grab Bag 1
Episode 16Tommy Taffy
Episode 17GREYLOCK
Episode 18My Wife’s Been Peeking at Me from Around Corners
Episode 19USERNAME 666
Episode 20Psychosis
Episode 21Midwest Angelica
Episode 22Feed the Pig
Episode 23Creepy Grab Bag 2
Episode 24Stolen Tongues
Episode 25UrbanSPOOK
Episode 26It Breathes, It Bleeds, It Breeds
Episode 27My Job is Watching a Woman Trapped in a Room
Episode 28Marble Hornets Pt. 1
Episode 29Tales from the Gas Station
Episode 30Marble Hornets Pt. 2
Episode 31My Husband has Taken Our Roleplaying Too Far
Episode 32My Dog was Missing for Three Days.
Episode 33Deepwoods
Episode 34SCP 3000
Episode 35Ted the Caver
Episode 36The Whistler at 3:03 AM
Episode 37Goatman, Laughing Jack and more…
Episode 38The Dionaea House
Episode 39If You’re Armed at the Glendmont Metro, Please Shoot Me
Episode 40The Only Other Astronaut on this Mission Died Six Weeks Ago
Episode 41Berries in the Window
Episode 42I Dared my Best Friend to Ruin my Life
Episode 43I’m Blind, I’m Not Sure How Many Steps my Staircase has.
Episode 44The Pigeons Around Here aren’t Real
Episode 45The Hidden Webpage
Episode 46My Crew and I are Stuck Aboard an Abandoned Ship
Episode 47Azalea’s Cookhouse
Episode 48Creepypasta Classics: The Rake, Candle Cove, Mr. Widemouth
Episode 49Dagon’s Mirror
Episode 50I Pretended to be a Missing Girl
Episode 51I Wrote Myself a Letter, I Got a Response
Episode 52The Red Tower
Episode 53Burgrr Entries
Episode 54Spire in the Woods
Episode 55Ticci Toby
Episode 56Greywater
Episode 57Borrasca V
Episode 58The Sun Vanished
Episode 59Camp Oakwood
Episode 60Ensorcelled in the Earth
Episode 61My Sugar Daddy Asks Me For Weird Favors
Episode 62I Work At A Half-Priced Voodoo Shop
Episode 63Mother Horse Eyes
Episode 64We Weren't Allowed To Talk To Women
Episode 65It Came from a Fan...
Episode 66Fleshgait
Episode 67The Church in the Woods
Episode 68The Ocean is much Deeper than we Thought
Episode 69I Clean Hoarder Houses for a Living
Episode 70My Little Pony Creepypasta...
Episode 71The Dead Girl in my Yard
Episode 72Polyamorous Hell
Episode 73The Flight Attendants won’t Stop Crying
Episode 74The Bloodridge Motel
Episode 75I Talked to God
Episode 76There's Something Wrong With Wendigoon
Episode 77Smile Dog
Episode 78Accounts From A Lonely Broadcast
Episode 79Room 733
Episode 80The Whistlers
Episode 81Journal of an Unknown Soldier
Episode 82Smiling Ones On Space Station Mir
Episode 83My Dad Ate Meat From A Deer That Walked On Two Legs
Episode 84The Bearded Man In My Window
Episode 85Dogscape
Episode 86Dreams Beneath The Witch Tree
Episode 87Stairs In The Woods
Episode 88Jane The Killer
Episode 89Drumming In The Clouds
Episode 90Marble Hornets Pt. 3
Episode 91TURN IT OFF
Episode 92I Found The Bunker Of A Prepper Family
Episode 93The Harbinger Experiment
Episode 94Something’s Strange About My Neighbor
Episode 95Happy Appy
Episode 96Rat King
Episode 97Ronald McDonald House
Episode 98HELP. I'm Trapped in a Sitcom
Episode 99The Delaurier Invitation
Episode 100The Scariest Japanese Creepy Pastas
Episode 101Necrosleep
Episode 102Whitefall
Episode 103Lucille's Late Night Snack Bar
Episode 104The Puppet In The Tree
Episode 105Confessions Of A Deep Sea Diver
Episode 106I Was An Air Traffic Controller
Episode 107Ad Nauseam
Episode 108The Animals on my Farm Kill their Newborns
Episode 109Point Pine Series
Episode 110The Slenderman Stabbing
Episode 111The Living History Project
Episode 112The Forest of A Thousand Legs
Episode 113My Property Isn't Normal
Episode 114The Moon Is On Fire
Episode 115My Dad Took Us Camping
Episode 116Gemini Home Entertainment
Episode 117The Man In My Basement Takes One Step Closer
Episode 118I Explored An Abandoned White Supremacist Camp
Episode 119I Got Hired at a Modeling Agency
Episode 120The Sandman
Episode 121I Solved The Fermi Paradox
Episode 122The Axe-Wielder
Episode 123Incel Horror Story
Episode 124Jeff The Killer vs. Slenderman
Episode 125We Used To Live Here
Episode 126I Work For A Private Museum
Episode 127Waffle House Horror
Episode 128The Antichrist Salesman
Episode 129The Lurker on the Stairway
Episode 130Where the Caterpillars Die